Training or Torture? Brutality in the Name of the Army on a Female Trainee
.jpg)
A recent video from Raipur Defence Academy has sparked outrage across social media. The footage allegedly shows a female trainee being subjected to extreme physical pressure—literally—as a trainer stands on her stomach in the name of “discipline.” The incident has reignited a long-standing debate: where do we draw the line between rigorous training and outright abuse?
1. The Incident: What the Video Shows
In a short clip circulating online, a female trainee lies on the ground while a male instructor stands on her abdomen. The act is framed as a demonstration of endurance and discipline, but many viewers were left disturbed by the optics and implications of such a practice.
2. The Culture of Hyper-Masculine Training
Military and paramilitary training institutions often pride themselves on toughness. But when that toughness crosses into humiliation or physical harm—especially when it involves gendered dynamics—it raises serious ethical concerns. Critics argue that such displays are less about building strength and more about asserting dominance.
3. Gender and Power: A Dangerous Mix
The fact that the trainee in question is a woman adds another layer to the controversy. In a male-dominated field, female trainees already face heightened scrutiny. Subjecting them to public displays of pain or submission can reinforce harmful stereotypes and discourage participation from women in defense careers.
4. Legal and Ethical Boundaries
While physical training is essential for defense readiness, it must operate within the bounds of legality and human dignity. India’s National Human Rights Commission has previously condemned similar practices in other institutions. If this incident is found to violate training protocols or human rights standards, accountability must follow.
5. Public Reaction and Institutional Response
The video has drawn mixed reactions—some defending it as “part of the process,” others calling it barbaric. As of now, there has been no official statement from Raipur Defence Academy addressing the incident. Silence, however, may only deepen public mistrust.
Conclusion: Reform or Repetition?
This isn’t just about one video or one academy. It’s about the broader culture of training in India’s defense prep institutions. If we want to build a truly inclusive and ethical defense force, we must ask: are we training future protectors—or conditioning them to accept abuse as normal?